Skip to Main Content

Insight

03/19/2019
Holland & Hart Client Alert

A Unanimous Supreme Court Decision Holds That A Copyright Registration Is Required to Commence Litigation

The Opinion
Last week the Supreme Court issued a unanimous opinion resolving a long-standing circuit split and affirming that a copyright owner must hold a registration from the Copyright Office before it can file a lawsuit for copyright infringement. The Copyright Act states that "no civil action for infringement of the copyright in any United States work shall be instituted until . . . registration of the copyright claim has been made in accordance with this title." 17 U.S.C. §411(a). Courts have been split as to whether this section of the Copyright Act required the Copyright Office to grant a certificate of registration (the “registration approach,” previously followed by the 10th and 11th Circuits), or whether that requirement was satisfied once an application was filed (the “application approach,” previously followed by the 5th and 9th Circuits).

This case was brought by Fourth Estate, a news organization that licensed works to news website, Wall-Street.com. When the licensing agreement terminated, Wall-Street.com failed to remove the licensed articles from its website, and Fourth Estate sued. Although Fourth Estate had filed a copyright application to register the articles in question, the official registration certificate was not yet granted when Fourth Estate filed its Complaint. The District Court dismissed the complaint and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed.  

In a 9-0 decision the Supreme Court (J. Ginsburg) relied on Wall-Street’s statutory construction arguments and affirmed the Eleventh Circuit ruling finding that “registration…has been made” only when the certificate of registration has been issued after examination. In response to Fourth Estate’s strong policy arguments, including that a registration approach is unduly burdensome on copyright owners, causes delay and limits their ability to seek preliminary injunctions, Justice Ginsberg acknowledge the issues, but noted there are issues for Congress to alleviate, and ones that "courts cannot cure."

Copyright Registrations
In addition to conferring standing for an infringement lawsuit, a copyright registration permits a rights holder to seek statutory damages and attorneys’ fees. Upon application, the Copyright Office generally examines and issues a registration in 6-12 months (average time 7 months). An applicant can seek to expedite the process to roughly one week for a $800 fee, although the Copyright Office does not guarantee it will be able to meet the one-week timeline. Moreover, if the Fourth Estate decision results in an influx of copyright owners seeking to expedite their registrations, we expect that that delays may become more likely. Copyright owners can seek statutory damages when they register their work either (1) within three months of publication of the work, or (2) before the infringement starts.

Foreign Rights Holders
The Fourth Estate decision does not change anything for foreign copyright owners who are seeking to enforce their rights in the U.S., pursuant to the Berne Convention. Foreign registrants in this position still do not need to hold a registration to sue for infringement in the U.S. seeking injunctive relief or actual damages. However, they still must secure a U.S. registration prior to seeking statutory damages or attorneys’ fees.  

Given these realities, best practices for copyright owners are to secure registration upon publication of their work. 


This publication is designed to provide general information on pertinent legal topics. The statements made are provided for educational purposes only. They do not constitute legal or financial advice nor do they necessarily reflect the views of Holland & Hart LLP or any of its attorneys other than the author. This publication is not intended to create an attorney-client relationship between you and Holland & Hart LLP. Substantive changes in the law subsequent to the date of this publication might affect the analysis or commentary. Similarly, the analysis may differ depending on the jurisdiction or circumstances. If you have specific questions as to the application of the law to your activities, you should seek the advice of your legal counsel.

DISCLAIMER

Unless you are a current client of Holland & Hart LLP, please do not send any confidential information by email. If you are not a current client and send an email to an individual at Holland & Hart LLP, you acknowledge that we have no obligation to maintain the confidentiality of any information you submit to us, unless we have already agreed to represent you or we later agree to do so. Thus, we may represent a party adverse to you, even if the information you submit to us could be used against you in a matter, and even if you submitted it in a good faith effort to retain us.