Skip to Main Content


Holland & Hart News Update

IBM Files Petition for Certiorari in ERISA Duty of Prudence Breach Claim

Last week, International Business Machines Corp. (IBM) sought Supreme Court review of a Second Circuit decision favoring retirement plan participants claiming the plan’s fiduciaries breached their duty of prudence in failing to disclose pertinent information with respect to the declining value of the business.

In Jander v. Retirement Plans Committee of IBM, Docket No. 17-3518 (2d Cir. 2018), the Second Circuit reversed the lower court decision and held that plaintiffs may pursue a claim under ERISA against plan fiduciaries based upon the notion that the fiduciaries knew that the company was overvalued yet failed to disclose pertinent information with respect to the declining stock value to plan participants.

In stating that one of the central tenants of ERISA is to protect beneficiaries of employee benefit plans, the Second Circuit concluded that plaintiffs sufficiently stated a claim for violation of ERISA’s duty of prudence. This holding, a departure from Firth Circuit and Sixth Circuit precedence following the Supreme Court’s 2014 decision in Fifth Third Bancorp v. Dudenhoeffer, creates a circuit split for cases targeting retirement plans with employer stock investments.

We will be following the petition for certiorari. (Retirement Plans Committee of IMB v. Jander, U.S., No. 18-1165, petition for certiorari 3/8/19.)

For questions about employer stock as an investment in your 401(k) plan, reach out to a member of the Holland & Hart’s Benefits Law Group.


Unless you are a current client of Holland & Hart LLP, please do not send any confidential information by email. If you are not a current client and send an email to an individual at Holland & Hart LLP, you acknowledge that we have no obligation to maintain the confidentiality of any information you submit to us, unless we have already agreed to represent you or we later agree to do so. Thus, we may represent a party adverse to you, even if the information you submit to us could be used against you in a matter, and even if you submitted it in a good faith effort to retain us.